HAFEZ
AL-MIRAZI, AL-JAZEERA: Al-Mirazi.
ZAHN: But as you know, your station has been accused
of using anti-American language, of running graphics
that feature and glorify Osama bin Laden. Even Secretary
of State Colin Powell denounced the station when
you repeatedly aired Osama bin Laden's statement
and Colin Powell said that that was vitriolic, irresponsible
kinds of statements. What is your defense to his
criticism?
AL-MIRAZI: Well, Secretary Colin Powell gave interviews
to Al Jazeera and later also said good words about
Al Jazeera, as well as Dr. Condoleezza Rice and
other U.S. officials. They respected the credibility
of Al Jazeera and the objectivity.
The problem actually is with the American media
and the Western media, who instigated the government,
and they always instigate against an independent
media like Al Jazeera, because they do what the
American media cannot do, which is not to mix patriotism
with journalism.
We cover a war in Afghanistan by putting both sides
of the story, the side coming from Kabul at that
time and...
ZAHN: Well, Mr. Al-Mirzari, I have to stop you there...
AL-MIRAZI: It's Al-Mirazi.
ZAHN: I think that charge is blatantly ridiculous.
AL-MIRAZI: Well, I'll tell you what is ridiculous...
ZAHN: I think if you watch the majority of the coverage
in this country...
AL-MIRAZI: Paula, what is ridiculous...
ZAHN: We do question the policies of our government.
AL-MIRAZI: Well...
ZAHN: I think we constantly put the leaders of our
government on the spot when we question...
AL-MIRAZI: Only on domestic policies.
ZAHN: ... the progress of this campaign.
AL-MIRAZI: Only on domestic policies. But in foreign
policy, you are just rubber stamping whatever the
government do.
ZAHN: Oh, Mr. Al-Mirzari, you're not being honest
at all.
AL-MIRAZI: It's Al-Mirazi.
ZAHN: Look at the debate in this country about the
Israeli's retaliatory strikes in...
AL-MIRAZI: OK...
ZAHN: ... in the Middle East. I mean you have read
the editorials in this country.
AL-MIRAZI: Paula, let me... ZAHN: You've seen the
front page headlines.
AL-MIRAZI: Let me just remind you of the CNN coverage
of what happened Saturday night, last Saturday.
For two hours, CNN was doing exactly what people
were criticizing Al Jazeera of doing, footage of
10 minutes coming out of Jerusalem, terrible footage,
of course. Nobody would allow or accept the killing
of civilians. But 10 minutes of footage have been
kept repeating all over for more than two hours
with commentators from your own reporters like Leon
and others, and adopting the rhetoric and the argument
of the Likud, not only the Israelis or the Labor,
but the Likud, and giving a podium for Mr. Netanyahu
and all the Israeli right...
ZAHN: I think, sir...
AL-MIRAZI: ... to bash the Arabs.
ZAHN: I have to tell you, I beg to differ with you.
AL-MIRAZI: That is not creative reporting.
ZAHN: I can't say that I watched every minute of
our four hours of coverage that night, but I will
tell you that as with all news organizations, one
would hope that you get on the phone and you try
to find differing points of view. We, of course,
had Palestinian representation on our air. That
is absolutely absurd.
AL-MIRAZI: But you give them a tough time the same
way that you are giving me a tough time. Had you
had an Israeli journalist with you, you have been
pampering him or showering him with praise, very
easy softballs. But only the problem with that you
get Arabs only to grill them. And this is the problem.
ZAHN: No, sir, that is not true.
AL-MIRAZI: There is no way...
ZAHN: I had the former prime minister...
AL-MIRAZI: Well, you did that with Hanan Ashawari
(ph).
ZAHN: ... of Israel on yesterday...
AL-MIRAZI: You did that with Hanan Ashawari.
ZAHN: We also had Mr. Barak on...
AL-MIRAZI: Yes, and...
ZAHN: ... and we asked him the question, why is
it Shimon Peres walked out of this meeting when
the vote was taken to possibly try to in some way
topple the government of Yasser Arafat?
AL-MIRAZI: Exactly...
ZAHN: Shimon Peres, we well reported the story that
there is a rift within the Israeli government, that
not all Israelis supported...
AL-MIRAZI: OK. You are defending Sharon.
ZAHN: That is absolutely not true.
AL-MIRAZI: You were defending Sharon...
ZAHN: There are...
AL-MIRAZI: You were criticizing the liberal, Paula.
ZAHN: There are people, as you well know, within
the Israeli government that do not support these
retaliatory strikes. I think our coverage is fair
and balanced.
AL-MIRAZI: Wait...
ZAHN: A final thought, sir, this morning on what
the goal of Al Jazeera's coverage is.
AL-MIRAZI: The goal is the motto of Al Jazeera,
to cover both sides of the story, the view and the
other point of view, to make sure that we would
have an Israeli journalist or an Israeli official
with us in the interview, deal with him with respect
the same way we would interview Arabs. And we would
also remind people with that word that you called
the ancient, Paula, yourself when you interviewed
Hanan Ashawari. The word is occupation. And this
is the word that we should always remember.
Occupation is an ancient, I agree with you. That
shouldn't have been, that shouldn't have stayed
in the 21st century and it is the responsibility
of credible journalists like you and journalists
in the U.S. to remind people that the occupation
of the Palestinian land should be ended.
ZAHN: Mr. Al-Mirzari, we're going to leave it there
this morning. But I do once again need to remind
you in our coverage with various guests we've had
representing the Israeli government this week asked
questions, as we have over the last couple of weeks,
about the settlement issue, which is deeply important
to the Palestinians, and also the whole issue of
refugees and their potential return if a Palestinian
state ends up being created.
So we...
AL-MIRAZI: When was the last time...
ZAHN: Our coverage has been fair...
AL-MIRAZI: Paula, when was the last time...
ZAHN: I've got to leave it there because we are
hitting a business news break...
AL-MIRAZI: OK, thank you. ZAHN: ... that is a sponsored
segment and someone's got to pay for these conversations,
Mr. Al-Mazari and Mr. Salama Salama. Thank you for
your time this morning.
TO ORDER A VIDEO OF THIS TRANSCRIPT, PLEASE CALL
800-CNN-NEWS OR USE OUR SECURE ONLINE ORDER FORM
LOCATED AT www.fdch.com